Reviews
Book Reviews
Reviews for
The Wandering Pirate Ship
Submit a Review
Brit G. - United States

When I review books, I generally try to give a fair assessment, including both what I liked and disliked. In the case of The Wandering Pirate Ship, I honestly have nothing negative to even mention in passing. The author hits high notes across the board.

Her writing is phenomenally descriptive and evocative. She creates enchanting scenes that almost remind me of A Secret Garden. From the beaches and flower fields to the wonderful cottage library, I can’t imagine a more lovely setting. I truly felt transported. One of my favorites passages (p.36): “As a cool northeast wind blew, [Lillian] reached to pull a strand of hair out of her mouth… Stretching ahead, she saw beautiful Cobblestone Island. A thin line of brilliant white outlined the western shoreline. Sunlight illuminated the distant cobble rows where moments ago she had dipped her feet and contemplated her first swim. Graceful seagulls flew in and out of the scene, taunting one another in playful calls as if engrossed in some kind of competitive game. A single blue heron stood on one leg, and red dragonflies chased each other across the rushes.” Wow. You don’t come across writing like that every day.

I also thoroughly enjoyed the storyline. I’d say the target audience is probably 5th or 6th grade, but even as an adult I found the story engaging and fun. Lillian, the main character, is complex and likeable. She is surrounded by wholesome adults and believable children. As Lillian learns and evolves, her journey is not only interesting, but also morally rewarding. The small illustrations throughout the book just make for an absolutely splendid reading experience.

I’m a mother of toddlers (and a bookworm.) Even before my children were born, I looked forward to one day reading my favorites with them. The Little House on the Prairie series, The Wind in the Willows, Robin Hood, Treasure Island, and now The Children of the Light Series. I don’t think Mary Schmal’s books are out of place among my list of classics.
L. Barnard C., Ph.D. M.Div. - Chapel Hill, NC

In The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, we have a brilliant, convicting, and inspiring depiction of how it’s easier to love in theory than in reality. Throughout its pages we see how humans can easily love the idea of the orphan or the widow or the child until we actually interact with another human – their needs, their smells, their sounds, and their personality.

In The Wandering Pirate Ship, we have a new portrayal of the difficulties of love – especially the difficulties than can come with loving those who are very near and close to us. The cranky storekeeper we know is harder to love than a bizarre pirate who appears unexpectedly. People who are like us are easier to love than those who seem odd by dress, habit, or living location. And sometimes anyone is easier to love than family – especially a sibling!  

In The Wandering Pirate Ship we meet and grow fond of a family in which Lillian has trouble loving her brother Thomas. Fortunately, Lillian is part of a rich community that sees the formation of her little soul and the development of her little personality as an important and worthy task, and so we see how fellowship and a community of saints can truly transform and touch lives. These deep themes are developed against a background of intrigue, adventure, and a well-researched novel that shows care for historical and regional accuracy.

The Wandering Pirate Ship is a deeply Christian story and depicts the Trinity in new and vibrant ways. The persons of the Trinity are real and relational as they know, protect, welcome, listen, heal, instruct, challenge, and love. The aim of the author to depict the Fruit of the Spirit (About the Author) is met well in that she depicts well both the glory of these fruits and the difficulty/impossibility to achieve these fruits on our own… it is clear that they are instead gifts given and made possible in and through our own experience of God’s love and grace. May we all experience this grace in deep measure and be inspired to respond in kind as Children of the Light.

Ruth G. - Milwaukee, WI
I truly enjoyed reading The Wandering Pirate Ship. I felt that by the end of the book, I had come to know and love The Children of the Light. I found myself wanting to keep reading, because I felt as though I knew these children and was familiar with where they lived. Can't wait for the next book, to see what's in store for Lillian and the rest of the children!
Deborrah U. - Waukesha, WI
The Wandering Pirate Ship is a delightful story that takes the reader back in time to an often forgotten aspect of US history....the story of families living at a lighthouse. The characters are contemporary in their childhood struggles and dreams of adventure. Pages of the story are filled with historical detail and enhanced with delightful illustrations. I look forward to the next books to see how the ‘Children of the Light’ grow and shine their light.

Ruth B. - Prescott, AZ
Striking a refreshing balance of descriptive narrative, dialogue, adventure, and intrigue, the author has cleverly crafted a charming tale that includes elements of humor and surprise. The theme of growing in love towards others is woven throughout, and both young teens and the young at heart will be enriched and entertained by reading this captivating story.

Sue F. - Manitowoc, WI
Just finished reading your wonderful cozy mystery book. What an admirable accomplishment, and to think you have more on the way! May God bless them and inspire all who read your Children of the Light series. My favorite descriptive sentence: “Lillian's thoughts were mazes of tangled vines, of branches intermixed with tall tree ideas in a forest of possibilities.”

Helen K. - Milwaukee, WI
It's fascinating how the author creatively intertwined stories from her distant family history, real Wisconsin history, and landscape into this enchanting children's novel. Reading The Wandering Pirate Ship took me back to when I was a pre-teen staying up all night to read adventure stories! I hope we get to learn more about the mysterious three sisters from Cottage Parakaleo in future stories! We all need women like them to guide us and live by example in our Christian walk of faith just as they did with Lillian. The scenic descriptions of the lighthouses, lake and islands throughout the story fueled my imagination and desire to visit northern Wisconsin landmark lighthouses.

RJ T., West Allis, WI
I enjoyed the hilarious nature of Charley and his conversations with the crew members. The mystery kept me guessing until the end. It showed me how little things make a big difference in life. Love is everywhere in Book One! 

Janet L. - Sioux Falls, SD
Lillian learns about love, jealousy and tolerance in this charming yarn, and the 19th century setting with lighthouse, pirates and shipwrecks makes for a wonderful adventure. An uplifting story that touches on kids’ real concerns. 
Madeline E - Pewaukee, WI
Amazing descriptions, such great characters and uplifting mysteries.
Reviews for
Moon Glow and Twisted Brew
Submit a Review
Prof. Deborrah U. - Waukesha, WI
Book 2 of the Children of the Light series continues to delight the reader. The richness of detail regarding astronomy is special. As with Book 1, the illustrations by Leanne Ross are truly charming. Each and every illustration is frame worthy.
Ruth B. - Prescott Valley, AZ
As the second book in a series of historical fiction set in imaginative Lakeshore County, Wisconsin, (closely tied to Door County) in the late 1880’s, Moon Glow and Twisted Brew, a.k.a. “constellations and concoctions,” is filled to the brim with educational appreciation for science, nature, art, and literature. There is plenty of adventure, mystery, twists and turns, and dialogue to keep the reader engaged until the very end. Most importantly, the characters develop and realize their unique strengths that reflect the Gifts of the Spirit as they walk as Children of the Light.
Dr. Janet L. - Sioux Falls, SD
Christian themes and life lessons clearly emerge in this second book from the Children of the Light series. It may be the 19th century on an island, but the situations these children encounter are familiar to any reader at any time. Why are some people jealous to a fault? Why does one's imagination run wild when eavesdropping on a conversation? How is it possible for children only on the verge of adolescence to witness to each other about the peace and joy in Christ's love? And just wait 'til you see the special artistic treasure in the middle of it all!
Marlie J - Luxemburg, WI
I give a 5 star rating for all of the books even though I could only check one “Moon Glow and Twisted Brew” (It is actually my favorite!). The books are all great and all include a great mystery and all leave you hoping for another book. I would suggest this for anyone. I do not have anything that I can say I do not like about the books. Also, the pictures are great! They look like a true artist drew them. Leanne Ross is actually a artist. As a result I think that everyone should read these books. I also think that everyone should meet Mary and Leanne because they are so nice. When I met them they were the first authors that I have ever met and they were so welcoming and they made my day! Everybody should read all 5 (soon to be 6) books. You will love them and the authors. :) 
Reviews for
Trapped in the Tower
Submit a Review
Terry W. - Rockford, IL
I bought the book series at the Pumpkin Festival, Egg Harbor, WI. I loved reading each and every one. Great stories. They are exciting and keep the reader's attention. Good for all ages. 
Michelle F. - Milwaukee, WI
Mary Schmal's Trapped in the Tower, the third book in her Children of the Light series, takes us along on an adventure with cousins Luke, Garrett, and their new friend Three Leaning Trees. The boys are eager to explore the world beyond the lighthouse and find themselves wrapped up in new mysteries, new cultures, and new problems! In the midst of their escapades, L:uke, Garrett, and Three Leaning Trees also discover their own shortcomings. and are reminded of what it means to be Children of the Light. Trapped in the Tower is an engaging story that will be appreciated by anyone who shares these boys' sense of curiosity and adventure!
Sue S. - Milwaukee, WI
This is the third book in a charming series about self discovery and development through childhood adventure, but what captures my attention as an adult reader are the strong female characters and the themes of Christian diversity and the unity found in Christ. In this story we see how people of different ethnicities, cultures, ages, and genders take up their universal priesthood and do the kingdom work before them. Each uses their Christian freedom, sometimes by making unconventional choices, to witness their faith and spread the Gospel message through words and deeds to the people in their community. This story also further develops the notion that Christian girls and women are not confined by stereotypes, but are free to choose the life path that suits them best when done in view of faith and knowledge of Scripture. "To God be the glory!" should guide us in all we say and do. Enjoy the read!
Reviews for
A Cobblestone Island Christmas
Submit a Review
Kathy L. - New Ulm, MN (Children's Literature Librarian - Martin Luther College)
It is getting close to Christmas and the children in Iona Bates' school are preparing for the Christmas Service. The talents of each unique child are tapped to help make the service special in many ways. But nothing like this is ever accomplished without a few bumps in the road. In the end, the message of the Light of the World coming into our world shines bright and clear. The author's descriptive phrases make the story come alive with the beautiful illustrations supporting and enhancing the narrative. 
Carmen R. - Hartland, WI (Teacher)
Hearts of adults and children alike will be warmed as they learn about goodness and kindness with the Bates family in A Cobblestone Island Christmas. Characters, relationships, and mysteries continue to develop and grow in this fourth Children of the Light story. Readers will be eagerly waiting for the next book to see secrets revealed and puzzles solved! Having read the previous three books in the series, I feel like I know the characters personally by this time. 
Grades 5 and 6 - Zion Lutheran School, Hartland WI
It's amazing how the author uses Bible passages and Bible truths to guide the Children of the Light through real-life problems so they can grow in their faith and in the fruit of the Spirit. We find it interesting how the stories are written using an actual lighthouse log even though the children are fictional. We also like how she wrote the stories so the reader feels a part of the stories and knows the characters.
Reviews for
Fireworks and Foggy Farewells
Submit a Review
Susan S. - Milwaukee,WI
In Fireworks and Foggy Farewells we are led on a journey of self-control and truth telling. We often associate self-control with bad habits. But what about when it comes to telling the truth? Thomas possesses truth that can restore his good name and provide healing for the troubled soul of Mr. Scarsley. But when and how should he share it? IS he even the one to share it? Who does he turn to for help? As Thomas searches for the answers to these questions, he and the reader are shown that love is the greatest virtue that guides Christians in all they do. Life and people are complicated, and we often need guidance and assistance in dealing with both. This book illustrates this need perfectly.
Paula R. - New Berlin, WI
I found this book delightful and feel like I'm on an adventure myself along with the children! I enjoyed learning more about Gwendolyn DePere, the differences between the Conner and Corwin sisters, and Captain Steele and his crew from his sailing ship, Wanderer. A mystery begun in Book Three is solved immediately. However, where are the red jewels? Will Thomas be proved innocent of his thievery? Read Book Five to find out!
Lynette O. - North St. Paul, MN
Who wouldn't want to be part of the big, fun loving Bates family! Mary Schmal's attention to historic details brings us right to the lighthouses in Door County, Wisconsin. In Book 5, Fireworks and Foggy Farewells, the nine children and their parents not only draw us into their continuing adventures, but help us learn important spiritual lessons along the way. 

Young and old will be drawn into the adventures in Fireworks and Foggy Farewells. Whether talking fish, missing paintings, or trying to keep an important secret, the Bates children and their cousins will not only share their adventures but help us learn important spiritual lessons as well. As always, Mary Schmal's attention to historic detail paints life in the 1800's lighthouses in a way we won't forget!

Reviews for
Keys to the Mysteries
Submit a Review
John L. - Milwaukee, WI
It's going to be okay!" In the sixth and final volume of the Children of the Light series, the nine youngsters of the Bates Lighthouse generation experience how "all things work together for good to them that love God." Mysteries are solved. Fears are put to rest. Growing up happens. The nine gifts of the Spirit have emerged. They blend, overflowing to touch the lives of many. When you read this well-told tale of Door County, Wisconsin, circa 1880, take heart. Smile. "It's going to be okay!"
Jon R. - New Ulm, MN
Expertly crafted, Keys to the Mysteries unfolds in many ways many readers will never imagine! Who doesn't want to know more about Cottage Parakaleo'? And yes, what about the three sisters? Aptly titled, this sixth book in the series answers many of the questions readers may have asked themselves while reading the preceding books. The details and dialogue continue to bring readers into the lives of the DePere and Bates families, along with the other villagers and visitors. Events, thoughts, and attitudes in their lives back in the 1800s have a striking similarity to many events in the world of 2021 as well. The author applies the Word of God in a straightforward and loving manner, showing application of the Fruit of the Spirit not only in the lives of the children, but also in the hearts and lives of the reader.
Leola A. - New Berlin, WI
All unsolved situations are resolved in Keys to the Mysteries, the final story. The solutions creep up on you while you read. Suddenly you realize this situation was in another book and now everything makes sense. The author shows how God works in the hearts of people and changes them without them even knowing it. Readers relate to the real-life characters and what they experience. While suffering a tragedy, you feel their pain and rejoice with them as they realize how everything happens according to God's plans. Their lives go on. They begin to understand why they are Children of the Light. These are the kinds of books to read in front of the fireplace on a cold night. I enjoyed all of them, and I am well into my golden years. 
Reviews for
A Cobblestone Island Fantasy
Submit a Review
Richard J. - Neshkoro, WI
After reading all six books in the series this book, A Cobblestone Island Fantasy, was a delight to read. Permit a couple of quotes to illustrate:

Like rain dousing a wooded patch of trillium, worry washed over Mary.

But hopefully, the threads in this intricate quilt of adventure will come together to present a masterpiece of understanding.

Speaking (or typing) of illustrations, the watercolors in this book are beautiful. Great work by author and illustrator alike. Thank you.

Joanie V. - Waukesha, WI
The Cobblestone Island Fantasy, is as the title suggests . . . a fantasy . . . but as its predecessors, the Children of the Light series, it is based on authenticated fact and personal experiences. The book is wonderfully and creatively written. The author uses picturesque adjectives and adverbs to make the characters, their actions, and the setting come alive. The book is also beautifully illustrated, in watercolor and photographs. The novel is a true example of a compassionate author and an equally compassionate illustrator. The book is also a sequel to the previous series of six books, the Children of the Light series. My suggestion to the prospective reader is to experience the previous books. There is a "WOW, I didn't see that coming" factor included in the fascinating book. Discover the surprise!

Share by: